An FOB price and a CIF price are not two quotations for the same package. They divide cost and risk between seller and buyer at different points, called for in the Incoterms 2020 rules published by the International Chamber of Commerce.

For an importer the practical consequence is blunt: an FOB quotation and a CIF quotation cannot sit in the same comparison column until the freight, insurance and destination charges are added. The lower number is frequently the more expensive shipment.

The wider sourcing sequence — samples, terms, inspection and shipping — is set out in our guide to sourcing vinyl flooring from China. This article deals only with the term itself, because that is where most of the confusion sits.

Eleven terms exist. For containerised flooring, six do most of the work, and the table below is the one worth keeping next to a quotation.

TermSeller deliversRisk transfersMain freightInsuranceImport clearance
EXWAt the seller's premisesWhen goods are made availableBuyerBuyerBuyer
FCATo the carrier nominated by the buyerAt handover to the carrierBuyerBuyerBuyer
FOBOn board the vessel at the origin portWhen goods are on boardBuyerBuyerBuyer
CFROn board at the origin portWhen goods are on boardSeller pays to the destination portBuyerBuyer
CIFOn board at the origin portWhen goods are on boardSeller paysSeller, minimum coverBuyer
DAPAt the named place at destination, not unloadedOn arrival at that placeSellerSeller in practiceBuyer
DDPAt destination, import clearedOn arrival, clearedSellerSellerSeller

Two columns carry most of the commercial meaning. The risk column is where insurance has to start; the import clearance column is where unexpected money usually appears. A CIF price looks complete because the seller has arranged the freight, but the goods are still the buyer's risk from the moment they cross the ship's rail at origin.

One detail causes more disputes than the choice of term: every term has to name a place. "CIF" alone is not a term, "CIF Rotterdam" is. A DAP quotation must name the exact address, not the city, because the difference between a port and a warehouse can be a day's trucking. Put the place in the contract, not just the abbreviation.

FOB requires the seller to deliver the goods on board the vessel. A container is not placed on board by the seller: it is handed over at a terminal and loaded by the port. The two obligations do not line up, which is why the ICC guidance for Incoterms 2020 recommends FCA for containerised cargo.

In practice, Chinese suppliers quote FOB because the market expects it and because freight forwarders work comfortably with it. The commercial difference is small while everything runs normally. It appears when something goes wrong between the terminal gate and the vessel: under FOB the risk has not yet transferred to the buyer, under FCA it has. Whichever term is used, the insurance should start where the supplier's risk ends, and the supplier should say in writing which point they treat as delivery.

For a buyer, the more useful question is not which term is theoretically correct but who controls the freight. An FOB buyer appoints the forwarder and sees the actual ocean rate. A CIF buyer does not, and the freight inside the CIF price is rarely broken out.

CIF obliges the seller to arrange insurance, but only to the minimum the rules require: Institute Cargo Clauses (C), for 110 per cent of the contract value. Clause C is a named-perils cover, and the list is shorter than most buyers assume.

It does not cover theft or non-delivery, and its treatment of handling damage is narrow. A palletised container of flooring — heavy, rigid, and prone to edge and corner damage — is not the cargo that Clause C suits best. Under Incoterms 2020, CIP requires Clause (A) instead, which is materially broader; that difference between CIF and CIP is one of the more useful changes in the current edition.

The check is simple. Ask for the insurance certificate, read which clauses are named, and confirm the insured value and the currency. A CIF quotation that says only "insurance included" has told the buyer nothing about what would actually be paid in a claim.

CIF stops at the destination port. Everything after that point belongs to the buyer, and in practice it is where the landed cost moves.

  • Destination terminal handling and documentation fees. Charged by the port or the forwarder, and rarely visible at quotation stage.
  • Demurrage and detention. Free time is typically seven to fourteen days, and flooring containers are heavy and need handling equipment. A delay in clearing or unloading converts into a daily charge against whoever holds the bill of lading.
  • Customs clearance, duty and VAT. Always the buyer under CIF. Only DDP moves these to the seller, and DDP is often impractical because the importer of record must be established in the destination country.
  • Inland haulage from the port. A 20ft container of flooring can approach road weight limits in some markets, which may require permits or a different loading plan.
  • Inspection and testing at destination. If the contract requires it, the cost and the time are the buyer's.

The same arithmetic applies to a first order, whatever its size: a CIF line does not include the last mile, and the last mile is where a narrow margin disappears. Our note on container fill and order minimums covers the loading side of the same calculation.

Is CIF cheaper than FOB?

No. CIF is a higher number because it includes the ocean freight and a minimum insurance cover that the seller arranges. It is not a discount, and it is not a delivered price. To compare properly, add freight, insurance, destination handling, duty and inland transport to the FOB figure, then compare the landed totals.

Which term should a first order use?

FOB is the market convention and gives the buyer control of the forwarder and visibility of the ocean rate. FCA is technically the better fit for containerised cargo and is worth using when the buyer's forwarder can accept it. CIF is easier for a buyer with no logistics capability, provided the insurance clauses are checked rather than assumed.

Does CIF include customs duty?

No. Duty, VAT and import clearance are the buyer's obligation under CIF and under CFR. Only DDP places them on the seller, and DDP is frequently impractical for an overseas manufacturer because it requires an importer of record in the destination country. A quotation that appears to include duty should be checked line by line, not assumed.

Comparing FOB and CIF quotations?

Send the two quotation lines and the destination port, and we will set out what each includes, where risk transfers and which charges are still to come.

Request a B2B Quote ↗